I really wanted to try both of these candy cane, pepperminty sweet 3-in-1s but I had to decide on one or the other...
I have tried several Philosophy 3-in-1s before. Some of them are right on. Some are awful! And then there are some that don't smell pungent enough or just lach the suds factor!
There is a $6 price difference between the two, so I was already leaning toward Peppermint Twist over Candy Cane... What pushed me over the edge was rediscovering the roll-on Peppermint Twist fragrance my mom- I mean- "Santa" (hehe) put in my stocking last Christmas. It smells sooo good! So I decided to go with Bath and Body Works' version.
I have already showered with this sweet, minty body wash twice, and I love it! It is crisp and sweet all at the same time.
Sorry Candy Cane!
If you have tried Candy Cane, let me know how you like it! Does it smell like the real thing? How is the lather? I want to know!